Welcome to Sweet Caroline's
Sweet Caroline's is a cherished gem nestled in West Rutland, Vermont, where food is crafted with care and tradition. This inviting eatery specializes in deli-style sandwiches that elevate lunchtime favorites like the grilled pastrami and triple-decker club. Guests rave about the classic French onion soup and delectable eggplant parmesan, highlighting the use of fresh ingredients and expert preparation. The attentive service and warm atmosphere create a memorable dining experience, drawing both locals and newcomers alike. Sweet Caroline's is not just about food; it’s about forging connections through exceptional meals that leave you longing to return.
Sweet Caroline's: Reviews & Ratings
Price don’t matter, you just come for actual good quality food. Burgers that are cooked to order and not just leftover from earlier. Having perfect cut sweet potato fries plus awesome service was the best. 1st time customer and want to come back more
Everything about Sweet Caroline's is "classic"! Our table ordered the popovers, french onion soup, two eggplant parmesans, and I had the chicken parmesan (which is my all-time favorite meal). Everything was classically excellent. The owner greeted us and was very kind. The appreciation was so obvious in his voice as he sat us at our table. Our server was really sweet and gave us the perfect amount of attention too.
Great food, and the prices felt very fair. Staff were very friendly as well!
Our waitress was wonderful, prime rib was fantastic, a little noisy but ok.
My fiance and I went for an early dinner date after two years of being home with our babies and it was AMAZING. We started with mozzarella sticks with the best homemade marinara sauce I’ve ever had. The prime rib special was perfect and the au-jus sauce just put it over the top. It might be our new favorite.
Amaizing place! 5 stars!!!! All food,like from home... Too much choices! Large portions! High Reccomend!!!
Hidden gem in Vermont. Amazing place! Dolores is the best waitress I ever met. And it is so amazing that the owner is from Texas as well. The food is delicious and good value! Highly recommend!
Wonderful experience. After picking up the wrong take out order by mistake, they went far and beyond what I expected. Multiple calls to notify me, a refund and a gift card. It's places like this that we need to keep in this community! Highly recommended.
Location
-
100 Main St, West Rutland, VT 05777, United States Hotline: +1 802-438-5696
Welcome to the charming world of Sweet Caroline's, a delightful restaurant located at 100 Main St, West Rutland, VT. This hidden gem is quickly becoming a favorite among locals and visitors alike, thanks to its inviting atmosphere and exceptional quality of food. With a focus on classic comfort dishes, Sweet Caroline's aims to provide diners with an experience that's as warm and nostalgic as a family gathering.
The menu offers an array of tempting options, including:
- Fresh Cold Milk - $2.75
- Cold Bottle of Donny's Favorite Root Beer - $3.25
- Chocolate Milk - $3.25
- Sweet Caroline's Deli Style Sandwiches - $9.50
- Triple Decker Club Sandwiches - $10.50
- Old Time Grilled Cheese Sandwiches - $7.50
- West Rutland Grilled Pastrami or Turkey Reuben Sandwich - $10.25
- Antipasto Salad - $13.00
From the moment you walk in, you will be greeted by a cozy and welcoming environment, where the love for food is palpable. The owner's kindness shines through, as noted by several happy customers. One patron, Mage, raved about the burgers cooked to order and topped off with perfect cut sweet potato fries. This commitment to serving quality food ensures that each dish is prepared with care, leaving you with a satisfying experience.
Food reviewers have noted the classic dishes, including chicken parmesan and eggplant parmesan, which are prepared to perfection. Michael Regilio praised their french onion soup and commented on the kindness of the staff—a sentiment echoed by many who have dined there. It's clear that Sweet Caroline's aims to create not just meals, but lasting memories.
Moreover, the prime rib special has become an instant favorite among diners, praised for its flawless preparation and mouthwatering au-jus sauce. Hope Tupper's experience embodies the charm of Sweet Caroline's, particularly as she recounted a delightful dinner date after a long break, highlighting the restaurant’s consistent quality and comfort.
With fair prices and friendly staff, Sweet Caroline's invites you to indulge in classic dishes that capture the heart of home-cooked meals. Whether you're stopping by for a casual lunch or a romantic dinner, this restaurant is sure to leave you feeling fulfilled and eager to return.
If you find yourself in West Rutland, don't miss the opportunity to experience the deliciousness of Sweet Caroline's. Call +1 802-438-5696 to reserve your table today!